Civil society members demonstrate at the opening of the closing plenary of COP31 in Antalya Friday. The session was later suspended until Satuday morning due to sharp disputes over a watered-down draft text.

ANTALYA – The UN climate summit entered overtime as its 6pm Friday deadline came and went, with countries deadlocked over a new draft deal that strips out every mention of fossil fuels, places a big bet on untested carbon capture technology and turns the hosts’ flagship electricity goal into an optional target that could be met by burning more coal and gas.

While one paragraph referencing health still stood intact, the new draft also stripped references to the health co-benefits of mitigation. 

Amongst delegates huddling in the halls Friday evening, there was little hope that a third promised revision Saturday would revive any mention of fossil fuels or yield other meaningful changes. 

If that is indeed the case, COP31 will be the second summit in a row whose main decision fails to name the fuels behind nearly 90% of the world’s carbon dioxide emissions. 

Only three years ago at COP28 in Dubai, nearly 200 countries agreed for the first time to transition away from the oil, gas and coal behind the climate crisis. At the time, the decision was seen as historic. Two COPs later, inaction is outrunning commitments as extreme weather and rising temperatures sweep the globe.

Conference follows escalation of climate-related catastrophes

Mud covers Nuwakot district in central-northern Nepal after devastating flash floods triggered by climate-related glacier melt and avalanche.

Recent events such as Nepal’s catastrophic glacier avalanche, drought-related emergencies in Pacific Island nations, and wildfires in North America have underlined how the “loss and damage” of climate change — a much-debated item at past COPs — is incurring mounting costs.  

Against those realities, the Loss and Damage Fund established at COP28 in Dubai in 2023 remains so underfinanced it can hardly function—with $ 2.8 billion in requests to date against $486 million received, plus one €25 million pledge from the European Union at this year’s COP. 

The second draft of the summit’s main political decision, released on Thursday, halves the first version to nine pages, also dropping a critical $120 billion target to help developing countries adapt to the accelerating impacts of the climate crisis.

The draft still backs efforts to “at least triple adaptation finance by 2035”, does not name a specific dollar target, and sets up an “Antalya-to-Addis Ababa Roadmap” that pushes the details to next year’s summit in Ethiopia. The text itself puts adaptation finance needs at $305 billion a year.

‘We didn’t come here to beg’

The draft’s single reference to air pollution, which includes powerful short-lived climate pollutants like black carbon and methane, has been cut.

“We didn’t come here to beg,” said Zanetor Agyeman-Rawlings, who chairs the African Group of Negotiators. “We came here to claim what is rightfully ours for our people who are suffering the brunt of anthropogenic activities of developed countries.”

“Africa is not a continent merely seeking assistance,” she said. “We are asking the developed countries to keep promises that they already made.”

The standalone health paragraph, a potential symbolic win for advocates that named malaria, dengue and cholera among the ways warming already makes people sick, now names no diseases at all. The surviving mentions of health appear in just one sentence, referring to “physical and mental health” and “climate-resilient health systems”.

Air pollution, linked to 7.9 million deaths in 2023, appears in neither draft, and the first draft’s single clean-air reference has been cut. Methane, which helps form lung-damaging ground-level ozone, gets a call for “reductions”, where the first draft wanted them “rapid and substantial”.

Food and agriculture go unmentioned. A few hours’ drive inland from Antalya, across the Konya basin known as Türkiye’s breadbasket, the government has mapped 739 sinkholes, some as deep as 40 metres, as drought and unlicensed wells drain the groundwater beneath the fields.

“If this version of the text remains, it will be a ghost COP,” said Mohamed Adow, director of Power Shift Africa, a Nairobi-based think tank. “The summit will have nothing to show for what happened here.”

“[The Turkish President] yesterday called this the best COP ever. [For] those of us who have been following these negotiations and have done so for 15 years, I haven’t attended a worse COP than this one.”

Big powers pledge to drill more oil and gas

US President Donald Trump meets with Russia’s Vladimir Putin and China’s Xi Jinping this week in Shenzhen.

Meanwhile, any decisions taken by the 190+ nations convening in Antalya may be overshadowed by the US-Russia-China summit in China. 

Speaking on Thursday at the three-way summit in Shenzhen, China’s Xi Jinping, US President Donald Trump and Russia’s Vladimir Putin pledged to “increase the production and supply of refined petroleum products for the benefit of all nations”.

The pledge was “part of the reality of the climate crisis that we as negotiators have to deal with as well”, said Wopke Hoekstra, the EU climate commissioner.

“There are some that don’t want that we use the words fossil fuels at this COP,” Carsten Schneider, Germany’s Environment Minister, told reporters on Friday. “There are some who earn a lot of money with that.”

“This process is completely unbalanced and unfair,” Sinéad Magner of the Women’s Environment and Development Organization told a press conference of civil society groups on Friday. “That is an abject failure of the presidencies. Your job is to act as an honest broker.”

‘High ambition’ nations fail to come through 

Laissa Baldwin, co-chair of the Indigenous Caucus

Magner and other civil society voices accused formerly ‘high-ambition’ countries in the EU, as well as Norway, the United Kingdom, Japan, Canada, and Australia, of caving to pressure on references to fossil fuels as well as other critical issues like a “just transition mechanism” that countries invest in green development.

“It is not due to the technical issues that they blame,” she said. “It is because they are completely resistant to providing any form of support to countries during their transitions.”

“There are countries who from the outset decided not to be a part of this agreement. There, they were plain and honest,” Agyeman-Rawlings of the African group, in an apparent reference to the US. “What we do not appreciate are those who choose to remain a part of the framework and yet continue to undermine the process.”

Larissa Baldwin, co-chair of the Indigenous Caucus, accused COP31 co-sponsor Australia, still a major coal and gas exporter, of betraying Pacific island states that face an existential threat from climate change. This, after months of pre-COP consultations when Canberra positioned itself as an advocate for its more vulnerable small-island neighbors. 

“These people are going to lose their islands, and I think Australia needs to get serious about what that actually means. “We have been through back-to-back fires, floods, super cyclones and also an enormous drought across the islands, so when Australia doesn’t show up in leadership in this space, it’s just a betrayal of the Pacific.”

Not ready to give up yet 

‘Our people are dying’ – Brandon Wu, Action Aid.

“People have strong views, of course. I am not stepping away from that,” said Chris Bowen, the Australian climate minister who chairs the negotiations. “But no one has said to me, let’s give up and go home.”

Bowen pledged to keep working through the “coming hours, for as long as it takes, to get the job done”.

“Almost 200 Parties own this process,” Simon Stiell, the UN climate chief, told reporters. “These are crucial days ahead for climate cooperation,” he said. “And we have no time to lose.”

Rich countries’ plans for moving off fossil fuels “are restatements of existing policy at best, and so it’s a smokescreen,” said Brandon Wu, director of policy and campaigns at ActionAid USA, part of the global NGO organization promoting climate justice.

“They are using the rhetoric around fossil fuels to make themselves look like champions, and then they pin the blame on us for lack of progress in the negotiations.”

“There’s nothing in this for us. Our people are dying,” Wu said.

Carbon capture instead of emissions reductions

Carbon capture and storage technologies can only play a minimal role in mitigating global emissions, according to Climate Action Tracker.

The first COP31 draft decision text urged countries to speed up “transitioning away from fossil fuels in energy systems”, the wording agreed at COP28 in Dubai in 2023. 

The revised text speaks only of an “irreversible global transition towards low greenhouse gas emissions and climate resilience”.

A sentence “welcoming” the Transitioning Away From Fossil Fuels Roadmap drafted by Brazil, last year’s COP30 host and published just before COP31, is gone, along with a call to phase out inefficient fossil fuel subsidies. Ending those subsidies is central to the WHO’s case for the health co-benefits of climate action.

Murat Kurum, Türkiye’s Environment Minister and the COP31 President, said there was no need to repeat fossil fuel language agreed at past summits.

“I don’t think there’s any backsliding,” he said.

The draft, however, calls for “accelerating” carbon capture and storage. The technology, which aims to trap carbon dioxide from power plants and factories before it reaches the air, is both expensive and unproven at scale.  

Critics say the deal’s focus on CCS, which today captures less than 0.2% of fossil fuel emissions according to Carbon Brief, is another concession to major emitters and the petrochemical industry — pasting a fig leaf over continued fossil fuel emissions. Groups such as Climate Tracker argue that CCS can play only a minimal role in reducing emissions given the lack of proven technologies at scale.

Kurum, however, called carbon capture an “important priority” for keeping industry running while it cleans up.

‘Selling us dreams’ 

Beautiful speeches while the planet is being destroyed – Juan Carlos Navarro, Panama’s Environment Minister

“They’re selling us dreams. They’re selling us a fantasy. They’re selling us lies,” said Kirtana Chandrasekaran of Friends of the Earth International. “They’re talking about CDR [carbon dioxide removal]. They’re talking about carbon capture and storage instead of actually doing what they need: emissions reductions.”

Carbon capture backers registered a record 700 delegates, according to the Center for International Environmental Law. Booming power demand from AI data centres is a key argument for the new technology, offering a “lifeline for polluters”, the Center’s Rachel Kennerley said.

The hosts’ goal of raising electricity’s share of global energy use from about 23% to 35% by 2035 survives, but it is no longer a call on countries. It now sits on a list of options for “global cooperation”, with a note that countries “will take different pathways”.

The first draft’s call for “clean electrification” is gone, along with its line that electrification brings benefits “regardless of the electricity mix”.

COP decisions need consensus, so even one country can block a deal. Tiny Panama has threatened to do so unless its demands, including a cap on oil production, are met.

“They are beautiful speeches,” Juan Carlos Navarro, Panama’s Environment Minister, wrote to the two presidents. “But while we listen to endless oratory, the planet is being destroyed.”

Image Credits: © UN Climate Change – Kiara Worth, UNICEF/Laxmi Prasad Ngakhusi, Chetan Bhattacharji, The White House , E. Fletcher/Health Policy Watch , Climate Action Tracker, E. Fletcher/Health Policy Watch.

Few small-scale farmers can afford to pay labourers to clear the stubble from their fields.

PUNJAB, India – Farmer Ravinder Singh looks worried. He has just harvested his rice paddy crop and hired labourers to clear the remaining crop residue from his field. But the window for preparing the land and sowing the next crop is narrow, leaving him little time.

Standing at the boundary of his field, Singh calls out to the labourers, urging them to finish their tea quickly and return to work.

He hires labourers from nearby villages, paying each around ₹7,000 (approximately $70) to clear his fields. The arrangement serves two purposes: it gets his fields ready for the next crop and provides fodder for his animals during the winter. 

“It is very expensive, but better than burning,” he says.

Every year, between October and November, farmers across Punjab harvest their rice crops and begin preparing their fields for the next sowing season. 

Nearly one million farmers in the state follow a rice-wheat cropping system, cultivating two crops a year. This leaves them with a narrow window of around 25 days to clear the leftover paddy stubble and prepare the land for wheat cultivation.

The system has played a crucial role in India’s food security. Punjab contributes around  46.24% of the nation’s wheat and 31.22% of its rice.

But the same agricultural cycle also presents a serious environmental challenge. With so little time between harvesting paddy and sowing wheat, many farmers who cannot afford labourers resort to burning the leftover crop residue as a quick and inexpensive way to clear their fields.

The smoke from these fires contributes to the seasonal deterioration of air quality across northern India, including in the national capital, New Delhi.

There is a short window between harvesting rice and planting wheat, so many farmers resort to burning stubble.

From October onwards, smoke from stubble burning in neighbouring agricultural states adds to Delhi’s already high pollution levels. Combined with Diwali fireworks, vehicular emissions, industrial pollution and dust, it contributes to a sharp deterioration in the city’s air quality.

This year, the problem was particularly acute around Diwali. On the night of the festival, Punjab recorded around 1,152 farm fires, while Delhi experienced one of its worst Diwali-related pollution episodes in five years.

The severity of the pollution prompted concern among medical experts. Dr Vijay Hadda, a professor in the Department of Pulmonary Medicine and Sleep Disorders at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) in New Delhi, told Asian News International that is was nothing short of a miracle that so many people survived.

Long-term consequences

The consequences of agricultural residue burning extend far beyond seasonal pollution episodes. A 2022 study examining the impact of stubble burning on air pollution in India estimated that exposure to particulate matter from agricultural residue burning was associated with between 44,000 and 98,000 premature deaths annually between 2003 and 2019. 

Punjab, Haryana and Uttar Pradesh accounted for an estimated 67–90% of these deaths, highlighting the significant public-health burden of crop-residue burning in northern India.

Both the central and Punjab governments have pointed to a significant decline in stubble-burning incidents over the past few years. According to official government data, the number of farm fires in Punjab fell from 83,002 in 2020 to 5,835 in 2026.

But these figures have repeatedly been questioned by scientists who use satellite-based observations to monitor agricultural fires.

In an interview last year with Health Policy Watch, Dr Hiren Jethva, a scientist specialising in remote sensing of aerosols at Morgan State University and NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center, challenged the official estimates.

According to Jethva, the actual number of stubble-burning incidents in Punjab last year was 10 to 11 times higher than the approximately 5,000 incidents reported in official government figures.

This year, Jethva’s satellite-based calculations once again estimated around 34,000 farm fires across Punjab and Haryana between October 1 and November 9, raising further questions about the accuracy of official government figures.

While governments have repeatedly highlighted the decline in reported farm fires and promoted agricultural machinery as an alternative to burning, the persistence of fires suggests that these measures have not fully addressed the difficulties farmers face in managing crop residue.

For farmers, the decision to burn stubble is not simply a lack of awareness about pollution. It is also shaped by the cost of clearing their fields, the limited time between two cropping seasons and whether they can access affordable alternatives.

Machinery subsidies are not enough for small farmers

Machines can help to mulch stubble, but these aren’t available or affordable for many farmers.

“Farmers are aware of the pollution stubble burning causes, but we are helpless. The majority of farmers in Punjab are small-scale farmers, with landholdings ranging from one to nine acres. We cannot afford to hire labourers to manually clear the crop residue,” Ruldu Singh, a prominent farmer leader from Mansa, Punjab, told Health Policy Watch.

One alternative to burning is mulching, an agricultural practice in which crop residue is spread across the soil rather than removed or burned. The straw gradually decomposes, helping the soil retain moisture, reducing water loss through evaporation and suppressing weed growth. It can also improve soil health and help protect.

Farmers can use several machines to manage crop residue through this method, including the Straw Management System (SMS), straw choppers, stubble shavers and the Happy Seeder. These machines serve different purposes: some chop and spread straw across fields, while others, such as the Happy Seeder, allow farmers to sow wheat directly into fields where paddy residue remains.

The Punjab government provides subsidies of up to 50% for some of these machines. But farmers say that subsidies alone do not make the equipment accessible, particularly for those with small landholdings and limited resources.

One major problem is that many of these machines require high-powered tractors to operate. Jarail Singh tells Health Policy Watch that most small farmers own tractors that are not powerful enough to pull the equipment.

For farmers who cannot afford to buy more powerful tractors or the machinery itself, renting is often the only option. But even this comes with its own difficulties.

Singh says only two or three such machines are available across several villages. Their owners generally rent them out only after finishing work on their own fields. But by then, the narrow window for sowing wheat is often almost over.

Even when farmers manage to secure a machine in time, rental charges pose another obstacle. Singh says owners often charge high rates per acre, and prices rise further during the sowing season when demand for the machines is greatest.

‘Farmers are already heavily indebted. Unemployment is so high that our children have moved abroad to support us. We barely manage to meet our household expenses through farming. If we keep paying such high costs, we will have to compromise on those expenses as well,’ he says.

These methods are known as in-situ crop-residue management, where the stubble is managed within the field rather than removed. Another approach, known as ex-situ management, involves collecting the residue and transporting it elsewhere for use.

Turning farm waste into biofuel 

On some farms, companies collect the stubble and convert it into biofuel.

For some farmers, selling or giving away their crop residue for industrial use offers another option.

Jagdeep Singh says the stubble from his fields is collected by companies and converted into biofuel for factories and power-generation plants. Unlike farmers who have to arrange machinery or labour themselves, the companies come to collect the residue.

‘They come themselves and collect everything from our fields. I don’t have to worry about anything. It is their responsibility,’ he says.

One such facility in Punjab is Sukhbir Agro Energy Limited, which reportedly processes around 600 tonnes of stubble daily. Estimates suggest that biomass plants across the state consume around one million tonnes of stubble. But this option is not available to everyone.

But Amandeep says there are no such plants near his village. He believes this is a wider problem across Punjab, where biomass facilities are not evenly distributed.

Farmers living within reach of these plants can get their fields cleared, while those in areas without such facilities are left to find other ways of disposing of their residue.

For farmers without access to machinery, labour or biomass plants, burning remains the cheapest and quickest option.

“To burn the stubble, all it takes is a matchstick and a few rupees. Every alternative costs much more,” is how one farmer explained the choice.

Ruldu Singh says farmer organisations have repeatedly asked the government to provide financial assistance so that farmers can hire labourers to manually remove crop residue.

They have also suggested that, instead of relying primarily on subsidies for individual farmers, the government should purchase crop-residue management machinery and make it available to villages according to their population and agricultural land.

He argues that many of the machines reside on larger farmers and rarely reach those with fewer resources.

“Blaming only farmers is easy. But without machines and proper support, how are we supposed to tackle this problem? We also have children. We would never want this practice to continue,” he says.

Farmers want financial support, not just penalties

The government has also proposed shifting away from the rice-wheat cropping cycle towards crops such as maize. But farmers say that changing crops without ensuring a reliable income could create another financial burden.

Ruldu Singh says farmers would be reluctant to replace wheat with maize unless the government guarantees a worthwhile price.

He argues that maize fetches around $100 per quintal and can be cultivated only twice a year under the conditions he describes. Without a guaranteed minimum support price (MSP), he says, farmers have little incentive to make the switch.

Sumit Sharma, a policy expert based in New Delhi, says the government’s response to stubble burning has remained largely reactive rather than addressing the economic conditions that drive the practice.

‘They see farm fires, impose fines on farmers and register cases against them,’ he tells Health Policy Watch.

Government data show that Punjab registered First Information Reports (FIRs) in connection with 1,834 farm-fire incidents this year.

Sharma argues that the focus should instead be on guaranteeing prices for alternative crops and providing financial assistance to farmers so they can hire labourers or access the tractors and machinery needed to clear their fields.

He says such measures would do more to address the problem than relying primarily on satellite monitoring and penalties.

For farmers such as Ravinder, the issue is ultimately about whether they can afford to clear their fields without sacrificing their livelihoods. He has chosen to pay labourers rather than burn his stubble, but acknowledges that the expense is beyond what many small farmers can manage.

As long as affordable alternatives remain inaccessible, the pressure to clear fields quickly before the next sowing season will continue to push farmers towards burning – despite the pollution it causes.

Image Credits: Arsalan Bukhari, Pexels.

Polio eradication
Women and children gather at an integrated community health outreach in Nigeria, where multiple health services are provided in one location. Children receive polio vaccinations, while adults are tested and treated for malaria. Such one-stop outreach programmes help bring essential healthcare services closer to underserved communities.

In northern Nigeria, a community organiser still gets calls from families long after a polio project ended. In Ethiopia, volunteers map migration routes, grazing areas and water points to find children formal services miss. As funding falls, countries must decide which parts of the vast eradication system cannot be allowed to disappear.

BAUCHI STATE, NIGERIA – Long after a polio project ended, people in a small settlement in northern Nigeria’s Bauchi State still call Rabi’u Baswua.

Sometimes they want help with a health problem. Sometimes they want to know when another vaccination exercise is coming.

Baswua remembers how different things were when his team first entered the settlement during a polio vaccination mobilisation campaign. One influential household head was firmly opposed to polio vaccination. His objections were partly religious: illness, he believed, came and went according to the will of God. He also distrusted the vaccines’ foreign origins, believing they might be part of an attempt to reduce the local population.

Baswua, Executive Director of Care Bridge Community Development Initiative (CCDI), has spent around 15 years working in community development and health in Bauchi. He knew that another outsider repeating the benefits of vaccination was unlikely to change the man’s mind.

So his team looked for someone the household head already trusted.

They approached a respected Islamic leader from a nearby community, explained the problem and asked him to speak with the family. The religious leader spent several days engaging the household, drawing on Islamic teachings to address the family’s concerns. Eventually, the household head agreed, and members of his family were vaccinated.

The intervention was part of community mobilisation efforts by Baswua’s CCDI, working with Nigeria Health Watch to support polio vaccination in Bauchi State. The initiative formed part of the wider National Immunisation Plus Days, coordinated by Nigeria’s National Primary Health Care Development Agency and its partners. Nigeria Health Watch’s civil-society-led demand-generation project was funded by SCIDaR, the Solina Centre for International Development and Research.

The campaign was only the beginning 

What Baswua remembers most is what happened afterwards.

The relationship did not end with the campaign. The community continued calling him about health issues and asking when health workers would return. More than a year later, he said, that connection has remained intact.

For Baswua, that is what makes the final stretch of polio eradication about more than administering vaccines.

“We need to use the people of that area,” he told Health Policy Watch. Communities need people living among them who can be trained and equipped with basic skills, he argued, so that they become the health system’s “eye” inside settlements rather than disappearing when a funded project ends.

For decades, the Global Polio Eradication Initiative (GPEI) has built a worldwide infrastructure around the task of finding and vaccinating every child. 

The programme’s infrastructure extends far beyond vaccination campaigns. It includes laboratories, surveillance networks, emergency operations centres, data systems and specialised health workers operating across countries. But it also includes people such as Baswua: local organisations and community networks capable of reaching families that formal health systems may struggle to find or persuade. 

In 2024, before the more recent funding cuts, GPEI had an approved annual budget of $1.1 billion, supporting an eradication effort that vaccinated more than 270 million children across 36 countries. Over decades, the initiative had developed what amounted to a parallel public-health system in many countries, with its own financing arrangements, workforce, surveillance networks and operational infrastructure. Although integrated with national health services and implemented through partners including WHO and UNICEF, much of this infrastructure depended on dedicated polio funding rather than countries’ routine health budgets.

African countries asked to chart a course on their own

Community social mobilisers wash their hands before the polio vaccination campaign in Hamar Jajab district in Mogadishu, Somalia.

Now, many countries across the African continent are being asked to preserve those capabilities while the programmes that created many of them operate with less money.

In August 2026, African health ministers adopted a 10-year transition framework to progressively integrate essential polio functions into national health systems. The framework calls for countries to maintain surveillance, laboratory and emergency-response capacity, strengthen routine immunisation and increase sustainable domestic financing.

But the handover is beginning before polio has disappeared.

The African Region was certified free of indigenous wild poliovirus in 2020, but outbreaks caused by circulating vaccine-derived polioviruses continue. These rare viruses can emerge when the weakened virus contained in oral polio vaccine circulates for prolonged periods in under-immunised communities, accumulating genetic changes that can eventually restore its ability to cause paralysis.

In its latest emergency assessment, published on 13 November, WHO reaffirmed that the international spread of poliovirus remained a Public Health Emergency of International Concern. Wild poliovirus continues to circulate in Afghanistan and Pakistan, while outbreaks of vaccine-derived poliovirus persist in parts of Africa, including the Lake Chad Basin and the Horn of Africa. WHO called for sustained vaccination, surveillance and cross-border coordination, particularly among populations that health services struggle to reach.

At the same time, GPEI’s  2026 operational budget was cut by 30% after major reductions in development assistance from longstanding donors. In October, its oversight board approved a 2027 operating budget of approximately $78 million, about $65 million less than in 2026. GPEI acknowledged that the trade-offs already made have affected the speed and scale of eradication work in some places.

The people who remain after the project leaves

Polio eradication
Children wait in line at a community health outreach in Nigeria to receive oral polio vaccine (OPV). Integrated outreach efforts like this help bring vaccination and other essential health services closer to families in underserved communities.

Baswua’s experience in Bauchi illustrates why sustaining polio eradication requires more than transferring equipment or budget lines. Community engagement in polio work is often funded through projects with defined start and end dates. Civil-society organisations are brought in, local people are trained, relationships are established and teams learn which households are repeatedly missed. Then the project ends.

The knowledge accumulated during that period does not necessarily move neatly into the next programme.

Local organisations such as Baswua’s have an advantage: they had established relationships with communities long before becoming involved in polio eradication. Communities knew them. They were able to discuss vaccination through local religious, moral and cultural frames rather than appearing as strangers arriving only when another campaign began.

“Since they know us, we know them,” he said of the communities in which his organisation worked. His concern is what happens when those relationships are treated as temporary.

When donor-funded projects end and established community organisations are no longer involved, years of trust-building and local knowledge risk being lost. 

Baswua argues that a more sustainable approach would involve identifying trusted people within individual settlements, equipping them with basic health and surveillance skills, and establishing lasting connections between those communities and the formal health system.

That approach would give programmes something campaign teams often lack: memory.

Someone would know which family moved, which household had objected before, which religious leader had previously resolved a disagreement; and someone would still be there when the next health threat arrived.

When the water is brown, vaccine is not the only issue

For some of the women, refusing vaccination had become a way of making another point: if the government could repeatedly find them when it wanted to deliver polio vaccine, why could it not respond when they asked for clean water?

Dr Adachi Ekeh encountered another side of the same challenge through Nigeria Health Watch’s SCIDaR-funded polio demand-generation programme in Bauchi and Kebbi states, which worked with grassroots organisations such as Baswua’s.

Ekeh, Director of Strategy and New Business at Nigeria Health Watch, said the project worked through local civil-society organisations because their members already knew the communities: including who had recently given birth, who had repeatedly refused vaccination, and which individuals carried influence inside particular extended families.

The programme used interpersonal engagement, community dialogues and trusted local voices. Nigeria Health Watch says the intervention achieved an 88% resolution rate for recorded non-compliance in Bauchi and Kebbi during the project.

But one of Ekeh’s most revealing encounters had little to do with explaining vaccines.

During a visit to Dawaki in Bauchi State, Ekeh sat with a group of women to discuss vaccination. Afterwards, their leader asked her to follow her to a communal tap.

Ekeh turned it on.

“The water was brown,” she recalled.

Families collected the water and left it overnight so the sediment could settle before using it. The women told Ekeh they had complained about the problem, but nothing had changed. Yet health workers continued arriving at their homes asking them to vaccinate their children.

For some of the women, refusing vaccination had become a way of making another point: if the government could repeatedly find them when it wanted to deliver polio vaccine, why could it not respond when they asked for clean water?

Ekeh said the complaint was escalated through the programme. By the time the team returned during the next phase of its work, roughly two weeks later, the water problem had been addressed. Women who had previously resisted brought their children forward for vaccination.

“That’s what builds trust in the communities,” she told Health Policy Watch.

Unpacking ‘vaccine hesitancy’

Polio eradication
A grandmother caring for two children raises concerns about polio vaccination misinformation during a consultation with a health worker. Such conversations are critical to the last mile of polio eradication, where building trust, addressing misconceptions and responding to caregivers’ questions are as important as delivering vaccines. They also underscore the need for health systems that can provide broader essential services beyond polio.

The encounter complicates the familiar language of “vaccine hesitancy”.

A parent may genuinely distrust the vaccine. But another may want vaccination and lack power to decide within the household. A child may live somewhere a team cannot reach safely. A pastoralist family may have moved by the time vaccinators return. Or people may interpret the intensity of a single-disease campaign through their wider experience of a health system that struggles to meet needs they consider much more immediate.

Ekeh described families questioning why a health system could repeatedly bring free polio vaccines directly to their homes. But when a mother sought to  treat her sick child, she often had to go to a distant facility. And even then, there might not be a health worker at the outpost, and if there was, she would have to pay for the  medicines prescribed.

Mobility makes the problem harder. She described Fulani families who could be present when community workers first engaged them and elsewhere by the time workers returned. Insecurity can halt work entirely. During one intervention in Kebbi, Ekeh said an attack forced people to disperse and disrupted follow-up in the affected community.

Professor Heidi Larson, founder and director of the Vaccine Confidence Project, said programmes need to distinguish between genuine refusal and situations in which the system itself is failing people.

“If the system is failing, you’ve got to work on the system,” Larson told Health Policy Watch. She said asking questions about vaccination should not automatically be treated as pathological reluctance.

Larson has studied the social and political roots of vaccine confidence for decades, including the northern Nigerian polio vaccine boycott of the early 2000s. She said that the crisis was never simply a matter of communities rejecting scientific evidence. Distrust was entangled with local politics, international events, earlier medical controversies, religion and household power. Some women wanted their children vaccinated but were unable to make that decision for themselves.

The context has changed considerably since then. But the experiences described by Baswua and Ekeh show why the last mile cannot be reduced to a simple offer to  people to accept two drops of a free vaccine.

The real  task is building a relationship that survives long enough for people to believe the health system will also deliver for them in other critical ways – beyond a polio vaccination. 

Ethiopia: vaccination in porous border areas

Polio

Experiences with polio vaccination in Ethiopia reveals another dimension of the same last-mile problem.

Legesse Kidanne, Secretariat Director of the CORE Group Partners Project (CGPP), based in Addis Ababa, said widespread hesitancy towards childhood vaccination is not the dominant obstacle his programme encounters. Instead, some of the hardest children to reach live in pastoralist communities, conflict-affected areas, border regions and settlements of displaced people.

CGPP works through a consortium of national and international organisations and community structures, supported by US Department of State funding. Kidanne said more than 5,800 community volunteers are deployed to support community-level interventions in Ethiopia, working alongside government health services to reach children missed by routine immunisation programmes.

Due to such porous border areas, Ethiopia’s polio risk does not stop at its national boundaries.

Poliovirus cases are also imported from  neighbouring Somalia and South Sudan, Kidanne stressed. Communities near international borders are therefore particularly vulnerable, while the mobility of pastoralist populations adds another layer of complication.

Finding the children who move around

A child is marked by a healthcare official after receiving the polio vaccination in South Sudan.

Finding those communities requires much more than maintaining a list of villages.

Community volunteers work with local leaders and health workers to map population movement. They identify migration routes, temporary settlements, grazing areas and water points where pastoralist families are likely to gather at particular times.

That intelligence is then used by health workers planning mobile and outreach services. In this setting, the last mile can literally move.

Children in pastoralist families may be in one place when a campaign is planned and somewhere else when it begins. Conflict can suddenly make a settlement inaccessible. Displacement can create new communities outside existing health-service maps.

“The routine programs will not reach those children,” Kidanne told Health Policy Watch.

Instead, programmes may rely on mobile services, catch-up vaccination and rapid outreach during windows in which insecure locations may become more accessible, when security conditions permit. The deeper challenge, he said, is maintaining continuity of both vaccination and surveillance in populations that formal services cannot consistently reach.

The human information network behind vaccine surveillance

Acute flaccid paralysis, or AFP, is one of the main clinical warning signs used in polio surveillance. It is characterised by the sudden onset of muscle weakness or paralysis, usually affecting one or more limbs, with the muscles becoming limp or floppy. Most AFP cases are not caused by poliovirus, but detecting and investigating them quickly, particularly in children under 15, is essential to determining whether poliovirus is circulating in a community.

CGPP volunteers receive training to identify and immediately report sudden paralysis and other priority conditions, Kidanne said. When a suspected case is found, the volunteer alerts the formal health system and may guide health workers to the child’s home.

Health workers investigate the case and collect stool samples, which enter the laboratory network for poliovirus testing and further analysis. A positive result can trigger an outbreak vaccination response.

The surveillance system is not waiting entirely for the family to find a health facility. “There is a gap between the community and the health facility,” Kidanne said.

Community-based surveillance helps fill it by complementing passive facility reporting with active case-finding. Even rumours of a relevant illness in a village can enter the formal surveillance system and be investigated.

The volunteers also identify children who do not yet exist in routine health records.

Kidanne described how community workers found newborn babies, recently arrived families, new settlements and internally displaced populations that formal vaccination lists could otherwise miss. The information is passed to health workers, who can then organise outreach.

Seen from this level, he said the polio programme is not merely a vaccine-delivery system; nor is it a set of neat digital data points in a surveillance report, it is first of all a human information network.

Who inherits the polio machine?

Polio eradication
Dr Mohamed Gedi (left), WHO Regional Polio Eradication Programme Coordinator, with Dr Mohamed Janabi, WHO Regional Director for Africa, at the 76th WHO Regional Committee for Africa meeting in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, in August 2026. The two hold a sign promoting the global campaign to end polio.

Dr Mohamed Gedi, Polio Eradication Programme Coordinator at WHO’s Regional Office for Africa, said the region’s new Framework for Polio Transition is intended to prevent that infrastructure from simply disappearing.

“Polio transition does not mean stopping the polio function,” Gedi told Health Policy Watch.

Instead, countries are expected gradually to integrate functions previously sustained through the specialised eradication programme — surveillance, laboratories, staff, financing and infrastructure — into wider health and emergency-response systems.

Some of those assets already have been serving  purposes far beyond polio, formally or informally for a considerable period of time, Gedi said. Laboratories developed for the eradication programme are used to diagnose other diseases, while polio eradication staff and surveillance systems also have supported wider outbreak response – and can do so more systematically in the future.

He described this as the logic behind the African transition plan adopted in Addis Ababa in August. It identifies high-quality surveillance, laboratory capacity, emergency-response systems, routine immunisation and domestic financing among the capabilities that countries need to sustain.

Difficult handover moment 

Some 32 of the WHO African Region’s 47 countries had already begun integrating polio functions into national health or emergency-response systems to varying degrees, Gedi said in an interview on September 2, 2026. In Nigeria, for instance, the government pays the salaries of surveillance officers, while international partners continue to finance some operational costs.

But the handover is also occurring in an increasingly difficult financial environment.

The 30% cut in GPEI funding for the period 2026–2029 means that transition may be more like a cliff. 

It will mean less money for the kind of local campaigns, human resources recruitment and surveillance that works in last mile areas particularly well. Unpredictable funding also threatens continuity because experienced staff may seek more secure positions elsewhere.

 “An overnight cut will result in massive disruptions,” Gedi warned.

Governments need time, he argued, to progressively increase domestic financing for essential functions including surveillance and routine immunisation.

The knowledge between campaigns

Baswua’s concern is that local programmes like his own can spend years building trust and local knowledge, only to see donors treat those assets as expendable when the grant paying for them ends.

He points to the Bauchi settlement where the household initially rejected vaccination.

A vaccination campaign could record the final outcome: children vaccinated. A database might record the number of doses. But neither necessarily captures the process required to get there — who knew the family, who understood the source of its objections, which religious leader could enter the conversation, and who remained trusted enough that residents continued calling after the campaign left.

That, Baswua argues, is why people within communities should be trained and equipped to serve as permanent links between their settlements and the health system, rather than relying repeatedly on temporary outsiders.

A border cannot stop a virus

Polio vaccination worker during a campaign in eastern Africa.

Ethiopia’s experience, meanwhile,  demonstrates why some of the structures built around polio eradication cannot simply be folded neatly into individual national health systems.

Kidanne said CGPP has developed local cross-border coordination involving health authorities, civil-society organisations, UN agencies and polio partners, including along Ethiopia’s borders with South Sudan and Kenya.

The goal is for local actors to share information and coordinate responses without always waiting for instructions to travel through national capitals.

In Gambella, Kidanne said Ethiopia and South Sudan have coordinated responses to circulating vaccine-derived poliovirus, including synchronised campaigns. Similar coordination has been planned around the Kenyan border.

WHO’s emergency committee has specifically called for stronger cross-border coordination and more equitable surveillance of mobile and high-risk populations.

As with national health systems, these cross border structures monitoring migrant and pastoralist movements  also have uses beyond polio, Kidanne argued.

A community surveillance worker trained to look for paralysis can report another unusual illness. A network that maps pastoralist movement for vaccination can help locate communities during a different outbreak. A cross-border coordination mechanism created because poliovirus moves with people can remain useful when another pathogen follows the same route.

At the same time, Kidanne said CGPP’s intention in Ethiopia is not to maintain a permanent parallel NGO system. The programme needs to work alongside established national structures. 

“Whenever there is project termination or phase out or any declining of funding, we believe these activities will continue using the government structure,” he said.

Success is ultimately the absence of poliovirus

A child being vaccinated in Sudan’s Darfur region.

Polio eradication carries an unusual evidentiary burden: success is ultimately the absence of something.

A country cannot simply report fewer cases. It needs confidence that a child who develops paralysis will be detected, that appropriate samples will reach a capable laboratory, that virus circulating in a remote or mobile population will not remain invisible, and that surveillance will remain sensitive long enough to show transmission has actually stopped.

In Nigeria, surveillance blind spots remain, particularly in insecure areas of the north and along the border with Chad, Gedi acknowledged. An independent review involving Nigerian and international experts was underway at the time of his interview to identify weaknesses and recommend improvements.

“We do have blind spots. We do have gaps in some areas,” he said.

Those gaps make funding cuts to surveillance particularly consequential. Gedi warned that poliovirus could continue circulating undetected for years, making continued monitoring essential even after transmission appears to have stopped.

“Even when you stop the last case, you continue to work on the surveillance to make sure that any residual transmission is detected quickly,” he said.

The danger, therefore, is not simply that shrinking budgets could slow the final push to eradicate polio. It is that weakening surveillance could leave countries unable to demonstrate that eradication has actually succeeded.

Accompaning podcast can be found here: https://open.spotify.com/episode/6GrkI79cgBIvYfZXzHpbwH?si=YrSSRycNSsqwphVNGrvRSw&nd=1&dlsi=df4391ee18ab44bf

Reporting for this article was supported by the United Nations Foundation Polio Press Fellowship.

 

Image Credits: HPW/ Paul Adepoju, UNICEF , L Pezzoli/ WHO, UN Photo/JC McIlwaine, WHO AFRO, WHO Africa, Jean-Marc Giboux/ GPEI.

Member states gather in Geneva as the WHO candidates’ forum concludes, shifting the race toward January’s Executive Board shortlist.
Member states gather in Geneva as the WHO candidates’ forum concludes, shifting the race toward January’s Executive Board shortlist.

Across two days of questioning, the seven WHO Director-General candidates united around scientific independence and country-level delivery – but diverged on how to fund the cash-strapped agency as the Geneva forum wrapped up on Thursday. Meanwhile, member states revealed their priorities for the coming years.

Thursday’s closing World Health Organization (WHO) candidates’ forum pitted a former banker, a Geneva veteran and a regional chief against each other. Budi Gunadi Sadikin (Indonesia), María Neira (Spain) and Hanan Balkhy (Saudi Arabia) fielded 43 questions across three sessions.

Each offered a distinct prescription for restoring WHO’s authority amid shrinking aid and deep budget cuts. Sadikin pitched development-bank leverage and pooled procurement, while Neira bet on climate-focused primary prevention and cross-sector persuasion. Balkhy, by contrast, leaned on measurable delivery tests, leadership accountability and building country self-reliance, drawing on her Eastern Mediterranean crisis record.

Indonesia’s deal-making banker

Indonesia’s nominee Budi Gunadi Sadikin casts WHO as a financial broker, pitching development-bank leverage and pooled procurement in Geneva.
Indonesia’s nominee Budi Gunadi Sadikin casts WHO as a financial broker, pitching development-bank leverage and pooled procurement in Geneva.

Across his session, Sadikin pitched WHO as a financial broker rather than a cash-strapped health agency. Drawing on his banking background, he told delegates that global health does not lack money – health ministers simply struggle to translate national plans into returns finance ministries understand.

He cited over $8.7 billion mobilised for Indonesia and claimed a call to the Asian Development Bank’s president helped the Philippines secure $1.2 billion. As Director-General, he pledged to help health ministers build single national plans and convene development-bank experts to fund them.

WHO “make[s] you healthy, [the] World Bank make[s] you wealthy,” he said, urging closer cooperation between the two institutions.

Despite telling delegates that as a banker, he believes in “underpromis[ing] and overdeliver[ing],” Sadikin laid out a sweeping set of pledges.

He promised to review and prioritise over 3,000 WHO resolutions with member states. He also proposed a dedicated team, remote robotics and fast emergency bank withdrawals for small island states.

On regional manufacturing beyond voluntary licencing, he pointed to pooled procurement – pledging to replicate the Pan American Health Organization’s Revolving Fund and the Global Fund’s Wambo system, alongside Gavi and UNICEF, to cut vaccine and cancer-drug prices.

However, on governance and treaty rules, Sadikin remained less specific. Asked for Year 1 reforms, he pivoted to grouping countries by chronic disease profiles. Pressed on binding benefit-sharing in the Pathogen Access and Benefit-Sharing (PABS) annex, he avoided committing – favouring “reasonable” not “abusive” investor returns.

Asked how an outsider would safeguard WHO’s scientific authority, Sadikin leaned into his lack of clinical credentials. Conceding he had “no medical background,” he said: “I have no intention to be the smartest [person] in the room.” Citing his pandemic tenure, he framed his job as funding scientists and shielding them from political interference.

Spain’s climate crisis candidate

Spain’s nominee María Neira argues WHO’s authority rests on scientific evidence, climate action and primary prevention in Geneva.
Spain’s nominee María Neira argues WHO’s authority rests on scientific evidence, climate action and primary prevention.

Despite Sadikin and Neira sharing common ground on protecting scientific independence, their perspectives on finances diverge. Neira argued that WHO’s clout comes from evidence rather than money.

“WHO’s authority has never come from the size of its budget,” the former WHO environment and health chief told delegates, echoing her campaign. “WHO’s authority comes from evidence,” she explained.

Having led WHO’s environment and climate change department for two decades, Neira used environmental health to prove that point. Tackling environmental risks could prevent 25% of global disease and death, cutting “around 13 million deaths every year,” she said. That includes “more than seven million deaths” linked to air pollution and climate change.

Rather than spending heavily, she bet on cross-sector persuasion – packaging health data for energy, transport and agriculture ministries at little cost to WHO. As proof, she credited London’s ultra-low emission zone with cutting air-pollution mortality by 40%, and China’s falling pollution alongside rising GDP.

She also urged building climate-resilient, low-carbon health systems to protect care during floods and heatwaves while cutting emissions. Even on artificial intelligence, she brought the focus back to basics: backing a global framework while noting remote clinics first need electricity.

Turning to internal governance, Neira promised “radical reform” and “precision surgery” informed by 20 years inside Geneva. In her first year, she pledged to build “One WHO” by aligning headquarters, regional and country offices. She also promised to link the chief scientist’s office with regional and country experts. Clearing an “unacceptable” backlog of internal justice cases would set “the tone for a culture that is more creative and respectful,” she added.

Yet for all her talk of precision cuts, Neira avoided naming what WHO itself would surrender. Instead, she argued WHO must sit at the centre of the global health architecture while donors and partners accept tighter discipline.

Saudi Arabia’s delivery-focused reformer

Saudi Arabia’s nominee Hanan Balkhy pitches managerial discipline, 100-day delivery compacts and country-level resource shifts.
Saudi Arabia’s nominee Hanan Balkhy pitches managerial discipline, 100-day delivery compacts and country-level resource shifts.

Saudi Arabia’s Hanan Balkhy pitched managerial discipline over sweeping promises. Calling herself a “hybrid candidate,” she asked delegates to judge her on “six tests of delivery.” She pledged to report back within 100 days, annually and at the end of her term, while creating a dedicated platform for small island developing states.

To show what that discipline looks like in practice, Balkhy pointed to her own regional overhaul. She revealed that she froze recruitments on arrival to audit overlaps and merged three dispersed immunisation and polio units. Globally, she promised to expand country-director training, building on her regional “boot camp”, and tie senior posts to transparent job descriptions, competitive selection and delivery compacts.

That same push against duplication shaped her view of the wider UN system. Proposing to replicate the Eastern Mediterranean Regional Health Alliance globally, Balkhy argued agencies must align operations beyond paper mandates.

Led by WHO, the alliance brings together 18 UN health, development and humanitarian agencies – mirroring UN country teams – to coordinate joint action on the health-related Sustainable Development Goals without encroaching on each other’s mandates.

Her crisis and pandemic pitch similarly centred on shifting resources to countries. She cited mobilising $1.6 billion in 2024–2025 – with 90% reaching country level – alongside $153 million from the Pandemic Fund and new Islamic “faith-based financing.”

However, she framed her ultimate goal as helping countries graduate from external aid altogether. “I shouldn’t say this openly, but I want to drive us out of business if I could,” she told delegates.

Where questions touched politically sensitive ground, Balkhy turned cautious. Pressed by Australia on sexual and reproductive health and rights, she avoided the phrase – promising science-based guidelines agnostic to “background” and applied under national policies.

Where the seven contenders agree – and where they split

The seven WHO contenders (from left: Al Kuwari, Kluge, Tamamyan, Song, Sadikin, Neira and Balkhy).
The seven WHO contenders (from left: Al Kuwari, Kluge, Tamamyan, Song, Sadikin, Neira and Balkhy).

Across two days of questioning, all seven contenders diagnosed the same crisis of trust and shrinking aid. Every candidate promised to shift weight toward country offices and anchor universal health coverage in primary healthcare. All seven pledged to protect scientific independence, while most backed reaching 50% assessed contributions and expanding flexible funding.

They also shared a reluctance to name specific global programmes to cut. Pressed on trade-offs, candidates pointed instead to future functional reviews, member-state priority-setting or partnerships with other agencies. Beneath that consensus, however, sharp divides emerged over who should lead WHO – and how to pay for it.

The field split cleanly along career lines. Three WHO insiders – Kluge, Balkhy and Neira – pitched institutional experience from Europe, the Eastern Mediterranean and Geneva. Three national health leaders – Al Kuwari, Sadikin and Song – leaned on domestic system delivery. Tamamyan stood alone as a clinical outsider, nominated cross-regionally by Botswana to challenge bloc politics.

Those backgrounds shaped starkly different financing pitches, even though all contenders backed aligning partners behind country-led plans. Sadikin bet on development banks, while Al Kuwari pushed the WHO Foundation and unearmarked funds. Balkhy cited innovative and faith-based financing, and Tamamyan proposed mass public giving alongside outreach to Washington.

On pandemic equity, all seven backed expanding regional manufacturing, and most urged finishing the PABS annex. Yet they split on how aggressively to confront industry and intellectual property rules. Al Kuwari urged completing PABS by May, while Kluge pledged to bring pharma chiefs to Geneva one by one. Sadikin pointed to Indonesia’s vaccine technology transfer with Senegal and talks with Ghana and Nigeria. Song backed voluntary licencing through the Medicines Patent Pool, whereas Neira argued WHO’s role is accelerating access rather than transferring technology directly.

The contenders also diverged on how quickly member states could hold them to account at the forum. Balkhy offered 100-day reporting and leadership compacts, while Tamamyan pledged annual public reporting assessed by the Executive Board. Al Kuwari promised a functional review, and Neira asked to be judged after one year on efficiency and culture. Kluge proposed a member-state review in his first months alongside a heads-of-state coalition against healthcare attacks. By contrast, Sadikin and Song offered no comparable 100-day mechanisms.

Multilingual banter and lottery luck lighten the room

Executive Board Chair Tandin Wangchuk (right) lightens Thursday’s forum with jokes about the token lottery and WHO’s language rules.
Executive Board Chair Tandin Wangchuk (right) lightens Thursday’s forum with jokes about the token lottery and WHO’s language rules.

Open questioning offered a rare human glimpse behind the diplomatic formalities of Geneva, with Thursday’s sessions delivering moments of levity – from multilingual banter to jokes about the luck of the draw.

During Neira’s interview, a question from Colombia prompted her to celebrate answering in Spanish, calling it “one of the most beautiful” languages. China’s delegate praised Chinese in turn, sparking laughter and a joke from Neira about holding a contest for the world’s top tongue.

She regretted not speaking Chinese, adding: “The important thing is that we can communicate.” Encouraged by the exchange, Executive Board chair, Bhutan’s Tandin Wangchuk, thanked Neira in his own language before suspending the session.

Wangchuk’s humour also punctuated Sadikin’s session as familiar delegations kept emerging from the six regional receptacles.

“Those member states who are getting [drawn] again and again, I think they should try some lottery,” he remarked, triggering joy among the delegates.

Malaysia’s delegation played along after missing out on several earlier draws, thanking the chair “for finally picking Malaysia” before turning to substance and offering a glimpse into member states’ priorities.

Member states reveal policy priorities

Uganda’s delegate presses WHO contender María Neira in Geneva on establishing a legally binding benefit-sharing system under the Pandemic Agreement’s PABS annex.
Uganda’s delegate presses WHO contender María Neira in Geneva on establishing a legally binding benefit-sharing system under the Pandemic Agreement’s PABS annex.

Over the two days, delegations across regions demanded stronger country offices, primary healthcare and emergency preparedness. They also united around protecting scientific independence, curbing agency overlap and securing sustainable financing.

Vulnerable nations pressed for urgent action on climate change. Caribbean island states and Egypt demanded climate-resilient health infrastructure, dedicated financing and cross-sector commitments. Thailand urged moving climate and prevention into core universal health coverage, while the Netherlands sought to shield climate science and reproductive-health standards from political pressure.

Member states diverged sharply on WHO’s scope and priorities. The United Kingdom, Iceland, India and South Sudan pressed WHO to shrink to core mandates and shed overlapping functions. By contrast, Malaysia, Brazil, Colombia and Uganda pushed for local manufacturing, technology transfer beyond voluntary licensing and binding benefit-sharing.

Middle-income and island nations also flagged being squeezed out of concessional financing and pooled procurement despite acute vulnerabilities. Meanwhile, sharp questions from India and Indonesia on artificial intelligence governance underscored deeper North-South divides over who writes global rules.

Industry set its own markers two days before the forum in an open letter to the candidates. The International Federation of Pharmaceutical Manufacturers and Associations (IFPMA) urged WHO to focus on regulatory strengthening, streamlined prequalification and clinical guidelines. It also warned against measures that “risk undermining innovation incentives or move beyond WHO’s core mandate and competencies.”

The road to January and May

The World Health Organization headquarters in Geneva, where member states will elect the next Director-General to lead the agency.
The World Health Organization headquarters in Geneva, where member states will elect the next Director-General to lead the agency.

With the end of the first public forum, attention now turns to the 34-member Executive Board, which meets from 25 January to 2 February 2027. The Board will shortlist five candidates, interview them behind closed doors and nominate up to three finalists by secret ballot.

Those three finalists will return for a second, more interactive candidates’ forum on 15 March. The full World Health Assembly will then vote by secret ballot during its 23-30 May session. Unless they clear back dues, 20 member states remain barred from voting under constitutional arrears rules.

WHO’s next Director-General will take office on 16 August 2027 for a five-year term.

Follow full candidate profiles and ongoing election coverage on the Health Policy Watch microsite.

See related story:

WHO Director-General Candidates Put to the Test in First Public Forum

Note: This story was updated to include the International Federation of Pharmaceutical Manufacturers and Associations (IFPMA) open letter sent to candidates ahead of the forum.

 

 

Image Credits: WHO, Felix Sassmannshausen/HPW.

ANTALYA –  Rising global temperatures are driving a likely collapse of the Atlantic Ocean’s circulating currents, threatening to reduce European temperatures by around 5℃, disrupt monsoon patterns, global food production and destabilise economies worldwide, a group of leading scientists warned on the sidelines of COP31.

The Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), a vast system of ocean currents often confused with the Gulf Stream, is an essential part of the climate system. It carries warm water north from the tropics, releasing heat into the atmosphere as it travels toward Europe. The cooled water then sinks and returns south through the deep ocean to be warmed once more.

This continuous loop helps keep Europe much milder than its northern latitude would suggest, while shaping monsoons as far away as West Africa and South Asia and marine ecosystems across the planet. 

Scientists cannot say for sure when the climate crisis will push it past the tipping point into collapse, but some put the odds of crossing it at about 50-50 this century.

“AMOC can no longer be considered a low-likelihood event; this is a high-risk global threat,” declared Johan Rockström, Director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research. ”You cannot kick the can down the road.” 

Despite the doom and gloom, scientists said a win-win lever to reduce the risk of AMOC collapse is rapid cuts in soot (black carbon) emissions, which would slow Arctic ice melt while reducing the health impacts of deadly air pollution.

Describing the threat as a national security risk, Rockström challenged ministers and diplomats from Iceland, Norway, the Netherlands and Finland who gathered for the event to tackle AMOC “as a national security issue.” 

“We have failed so far in terms of delivering against the Paris Agreement,” Rockström added. “That’s the problem. We have to halt global warming.”

New European ice age, Africa and Asia food production interrupted

Almost all of Europe and the Arctic has warmed over the past 30 years, parts of the Arctic by more than 1℃ every decade. The exception is a patch of ocean south of Greenland (in blue) that has cooled slightly, a “cold blob” scientists see as a possible sign that the AMOC is slowing.

While a precise date for an AMOC collapse is impossible to determine, scientists see warning signs suggesting the vital circulation system could be approaching a dangerous tipping point. 

Sea-level warning and Arctic ice melt, potentially weakening or collapsing the Atlantic Ocean’s circulatory system, would set in motion changes that would be extremely difficult, if not impossible, to reverse.

While a dramatic reduction in average European temperatures of 5℃ or more might be the most immediate impact, effects would not stop at Europe’s borders.

Australian climate scientist Bill Hare warned that AMOC disruption could affect major weather systems associated with West African and South Asian monsoons. Rainfall disruption, in turn, would have profound consequences for agricultural production and the survival of communities already vulnerable to climate change. 

The consequences of a full-scale collapse could be so extensive that conventional climate adaptation strategies might prove inadequate, Hare warned, adding that an AMOC collapse is something that governments need to prevent rather than prepare to manage — the de facto response to many climate change impacts to date. 

“It’s a sort of event that one needs to avoid,” Hare said.

No longer a ‘low-likelihood’ event  

A patch of the North Atlantic south of Greenland, known as the “cold blob,” is the only area on this map to have cooled between 1996 and 2025. Climate models have long predicted such a cold patch as a possible fingerprint of a slowing AMOC.

Today, the AMOC transports heat to northern latitudes equivalent to 15 times the annual energy use of all humanity, Professor Stephen Rahmstorf of the University of Potsdam said, underscoring the power of the circulating system. 

Direct measurements of the AMOC only began in 2004, making it difficult to establish a long-term record. Nevertheless, Rahmstorf said several independent indicators are converging to suggest a decline in the circulation pattern in the AMOC systems across the Atlantic Ocean. 

One critical warning sign is a cold patch in the northern Atlantic surrounded by waters and land areas experiencing rising temperatures. Climate models have long predicted this pattern as a possible fingerprint of a slowing AMOC.

Unusual warming along the Eastern coast of the United States, associated with a northward shift of the Gulf Stream, is another sign of changes in the circulation system, the scientists said. 

Crossing the tipping point would not necessarily involve immediate, dramatic changes, he warned. However, once the AMOC system’s slowdown passes a critical threshold, the process will likely be irreversible because of self-reinforcing feedbacks within the ocean system.

“AMOC shutdown is not a low likelihood event anymore,” Rahmstorf declared. “It starts to look likely. I tend to say 50-50 [probability], maybe even more. And the point of no return may be passed very soon, in a few decades.”

And the point of no return could be reached within the coming decades, Rahmstorf said, adding that even if a full shutdown is only reached around 2100, “the impact on that will show up much earlier.”

Changes around Antarctica also signal more ocean tipping points

Climate models used in the UN climate science panel’s 2021 assessment project the AMOC will weaken steadily under all four emissions scenarios shown (coloured lines), slowing by about 5 million cubic metres of water per second by 2100. Direct measurements (green) began only in 2004.

Across the planet, the oceans absorb enormous quantities of heat and human-produced carbon, slowing the pace of climate change experienced by people on land. They are the planet’s largest natural carbon sink, even ahead of rainforests, absorbing 29% of the carbon dioxide released by human activity over the past decade.

The knock-on effects mean that changes in ocean circulation in one part of the planet are not a regional phenomenon, but one with consequences across the entire planet.

Alongside AMOC, the Southern Ocean’s overturning circulation system around Antarctica is also weakening, with the latest research on Antarctic ice melt suggesting a potentially faster decline than conventional climate models, noted Professor Michael Meredith, a leading UK ocean and climate scientist.

The implications include declining oxygen levels in the deep ocean, reduced biological productivity, a weaker carbon sink and potentially faster Antarctic ice loss, contributing to rising sea levels worldwide.

The danger is that multiple systems coming under pressure simultaneously could produce cascading consequences much greater than those associated with any individual event, said Iceland’s Minister for the Environment, Energy and Climate, Jóhann Jóhannsson. 

“We do not know the exact probability of AMOC collapse, but all the evidence points in the same direction: greater greenhouse gas emissions increase the risk. Rapid emissions reductions reduce the risk,” he said.

AMOC as a national security risk

Dense water sinking around Antarctica drives a second overturning circulation that spreads through the world’s oceans (map, right). Observations show this outflow has already slowed by 30% or more in some sectors.

For Iceland, an AMOC collapse could not only bring colder winters and longer periods of sea ice, but a cascade of other impacts on marine ecosystems and fisheries, farming and energy supplies, Jóhannsson predicted.

“A major weakening of the AMOC could simultaneously affect food security, energy systems, infrastructure, maritime transport, public finances, and overall societal resilience,” he said.

As a result, Iceland’s government has already begun examining potential AMOC collapse as a national security threat, he told the meeting.

“The systems upon which our prosperity depends could be transformed, and this is not only Iceland’s problem. We don’t have any time to lose; we must act before it is too late.”

Against an otherwise gloomy picture of trends around the Atlantic current, rapid reductions of short-lived climate pollutants, also called superpollutants, could put the brakes on warming — even more immediately than reductions in CO2 emissions. 

Superpollutants such as black carbon, methane and hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) warm the planet dozens, hundreds or even thousands of times more than CO2, tonne for tonne, but leave the atmosphere far sooner. Black carbon lingers for just four to 12 days, while CO2 can persist for centuries. If the emissions pump is switched off, the benefits are almost immediate.

Rapid Black Carbon reductions could slow AMOC’s decline

For Arctic ice melt, reducing black carbon emissions can be an even more powerful lever, Pam Pearson of the International Cryosphere Climate Initiative (ICCI), one of five other co-sponsors of the event led by Iceland, told Health Policy Watch. 

Because black carbon absorbs sunlight directly, interacts with clouds, and darkens snow and ice, its ‘global warming potential’ per unit of emissions can be up to 6,200 times more powerful than CO2 in Arctic regions.  

Key black carbon sources around the world include emissions from building and residential heating (in developing as well as developed countries); diesel vehicles and generators, waste incineration and wildfires.

“The risk of AMOC collapse, according to the scientists here at COP311 may already be higher than 50%,” Pearson warned. “Models show that risk as lower only with limited overshoot of the 1.5℃ global warming benchmark, with a return to 1.5℃, or below, by the end of this century.

To make that happen, CO2 emissions need to reduce rapidly, by about 5% a year, beginning now.

“The only other feasible levers available to us to decrease temperatures rapidly are reforestation and short-lived climate pollution reductions,” Pearson added.

“In addition to methane, this needs to include black carbon reductions, particularly near the Arctic, because a decrease in deposited black carbon will slow sea ice loss and Greenland ice sheet melt; both associated with AMOC slowdown.  

Since black carbon comprises a significant part of air pollution, which kills over 7 million people a year, reducing BC pollution emissions would also carry a strong health benefit as well, she said.  

“These reductions also, of course, carry strong health benefits in the Arctic and other communities where burning occurs, especially from heating stoves, marine and diesel transport, waste incineration and agricultural fires – plus the wildfires that spread from uncontrolled burning.”

Wild fires
Fires have been raging across Indonesia due to dry conditions linked to climate change, combined with the El Niño conditions.

Worsening heat, dry weather due to climate change, and strong El Niño conditions have fueled some of the most intense fire activity to sweep across the islands in Indonesia and Papua New Guinea during this year’s dry season.

Deaths and respiratory issues have been reported across several nations in the region, and economic damages already run in the billions.

Copernicus Atmosphere Monitoring Service (CAMS), one of the services of the European Union’s Earth Observation Programme, has described this year’s fire activity as “exceptional” in its report released on Thursday.

“One thing that stands out this year is the persistence of the fires and the substantial differences between Indonesia’s provinces,” said  said Mark Parrington, European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) scientist for CAMS. “Our forecasts have highlighted the severe and prolonged air quality impacts of the haze and regional smoke transport across the country and wider Maritime Continent, resulting in significant health issues and poor visibility.”

Health impacts across borders

Kuala Lumpur engulfed in smog due to the forest fires in Indonesia. 

The blazes across Indonesia have burnt over 88,000 km2, claiming lives, causing widespread respiratory illness, affecting endangered animals, and disrupting global supply chains.

According to the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air (CRECA), smoke from these fires has so far resulted in the deaths of over 5,250 people and 400,000 respiratory infections across the country.

It has also degraded air quality in Singapore, Malaysia and the Philippines. Singapore experienced one of its worst haze episodes in years, with an economic cost estimated in the billions of dollars.

Months of poor air quality

PM2.5 surface concentration over Indonesia and the southern ASEAN region from the CAMS o-suite forecasts initialised at 00 UTC, and valid for each day from 1 October to 15 November.

Air pollution has been poor across several countries in the Southeast Asia region since September this year, as air pollution can travel hundreds of kilometres away from the source with the right wind speed.

By 15 November, total estimated fire emissions for Indonesia for the year were the third highest since 2003, releasing 200 megatonnes of carbon (Mt C).

This year’s emissions were close to the second-highest levels (in 2006) but far from the record (2015), which reached nearly 400 Mt C, per CAMS Global Fire Assimilation System (GFAS) data.

Notably, both 2006 and 2015 were also El Niño years. Meanwhile, the total emissions from fires in neighbouring country Papua New Guinea were the second highest since 2003, tracking closely to the current record, set in 2015.

Also read: Indonesian Wildfires Cause Air Pollution Levels to Rise to Hazardous Levels in Southeast Asia

Record levels of fires in Indonesia

Cumulative daily total estimated emissions of carbon from fires in Indonesia from 2003 to 2026.

Though consistent with fire emissions for Indonesia seen in El Niño years, this year’s levels were well above those recorded in recent years. The 2026 fire emissions also starkly contrasted those of last year’s dry season, which were particularly low.

Indonesia has made substantial efforts to reduce the frequency and intensity of seasonal fires, with help from other ASEAN countries – a group of 11 regional nations.

Fires driven by El Niño and climate change

Fires leave peatlands vulnerable to burning. Peatlands store large amounts of carbon and are areas where water logging prevents plants from fully decomposing.

While El Niño is a natural phenomenon, it tends to intensify dry conditions in and around southeast Asia, increasing the risk of blazes. It also leaves peatlands – ecosystems that provide unique habitats and store large amounts of carbon – which have been drained for agriculture particularly vulnerable to burning.

Fires in peat that has been drained can burn underground and smoulder for long periods of time, releasing large amounts of smoke pollution and greenhouse gases into the atmosphere.

“High temperatures and a lack of rainfall (precipitation), driven by strong El Niño conditions and human-induced climate change, favoured this exceptional fire season. CAMS data show that El Niño can be a contributor to major blazes across Southeast Asia, but it is not the only factor,” concluded Laurence Rouil, director of CAMS.

Image Credits: Copernicus, Minh Tran, CAMS, CAMS Global Fire Assimilation System v1.2., International Peatland Society.

Diabetes
A woman living with type 1 diabetes administers an insulin injection at home in Kumi, Uganda.

The guidelines publication coincided with World Diabetes Day, where the World Health Organization (WHO) aims to support countries in tackling the growing inequities in diabetes care.

Before the discovery of insulin over a century ago, type 1 diabetes (T1D) was a death sentence.  People with the condition, where the body produces little or no insulin, require lifelong daily insulin treatment to survive. 

Yet in many low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), survival remains closely linked to the strength of the health care system. Limited access to insulin and blood glucose monitoring, shortages of trained health care workers and high out-of-pocket costs continue to result in preventable morbidity and premature mortality, according to the WHO.

In humanitarian crises and emergency settings, access to insulin may be even more complicated, leaving people living with T1D particularly vulnerable.

In these fraught settings, interrupted supply chains, unreliable refrigeration – necessary for insulin storage – and limited health worker experience in insulin management can reduce diabetes care to life- or death situations. 

With these inequities in mind, WHO has published its first dedicated guidelines on insulin use for adults with type 1 diabetes in a wide range of environments, including humanitarian settings.

“Ultimately, the goal is simple: to help ensure that everyone living with type 1 diabetes can access quality, lifesaving care, wherever they live,” said Dr Bianca Hemmingsen, technical lead for WHO’s Diabetes Programme, in a statement to Health Policy Watch.

Addressing inequities

Insulin diabetes
Type 1 diabetes is growing in developing nations.

The guidelines seek to address longstanding inequities in access to diabetes care through recommendations for diagnosis, insulin use, and glycaemic monitoring. The guideline is intended to support health care providers, policymakers, and humanitarian organizations in ensuring care for adults with T1D.

Out of the 14 recommendations WHO makes, it strongly recommends one: Use intensified insulin therapy – multiple daily injections with dose adjustment to blood glucose values – for adults with T1D. 

The guidelines also recommend regular monitoring of blood glucose levels. In clinical settings, this could mean a regular blood test that shows average blood sugar levels over the past few months. At home, WHO recommends checking levels with a finger prick test or a continuous glucose monitor, through a small sensor worn on the skin. Where blood glucose testing is not available, urine glucose testing can be considered, WHO said in a press release, accompanying the technical document.

Global burden 

Type 1 diabetes map
Type 1 diabetes, a chronic autoimmune disorder that causes the body to produce little or no insulin, is increasing globally.

Premature mortality caused by diabetes has continued to increase in recent decades, unlike other major non-communicable diseases (NCD),  cardiovascular and respiratory diseases and cancer. 

An estimated 9.5 million people were living with type 1 diabetes globally in 2025, with more than 500,000 new cases diagnosed that year, according to WHO. Although the condition has historically been associated with childhood and adolescence, up to half of all people with type 1 diabetes are diagnosed in adulthood. 

Unlike type 2 diabetes, T1D is an autoimmune disorder in which the body’s immune system attacks insulin-producing cells, meaning the body produces little or no insulin. This leads to high blood glucose levels, requiring daily insulin treatment to survive.

Along with the challenge of accessing insulin at all, people with type 1 diabetes frequently experience “fragmented care, limited access to specialist support and inconsistent follow-up, increasing the risk of acute metabolic complications and long-term complications,” WHO said in the guidelines’ executive summary.

“For people with type 1 diabetes, insulin is a matter of survival. More than a century after insulin was discovered, where a child is born still largely decides whether they will live a long, healthy life with the condition,” said Dr Peter Schwarz, president of the International Diabetes Federation. 

“The Type 1 Diabetes Index estimates that the remaining life expectancy of a 10-year-old diagnosed in 2025 ranges from just 6 years in very disadvantaged countries to more than 60 in others,” he explained in a statement to Health Policy Watch. 

Particularly in low-income settings, up to 40% of type 1 diabetes cases may initially be misdiagnosed with the more common type 2 form of diabetes, delaying care and undermining treatment, Schwarz added. 

In response, the WHO launched the Global Diabetes Compact in 2021 – an initiative to respond to the rising impact of diabetes worldwide. In 2022, WHO member states endorsed five global diabetes coverage targets, including a commitment that 100% of people with type 1 diabetes should have access to affordable insulin and blood glucose self-monitoring by 2030. 

Intensified insulin therapy

Existing clinical guidance on insulin use has largely been developed by health systems in high-income countries, often assuming reliable supply chains, access to advanced monitoring technologies and specialist-led care. 

WHO’s new global guidelines seek to provide recommendations that can be adapted across different levels of health system capacity. Key among those include:

  • A strong WHO recommendation for intensified insulin therapy for adults with T1D. The regimen typically involves three or more daily injections, combining a basal insulin dose – which maintains glucose levels throughout the day – with additional doses of bolus insulin around mealtimes. Doses should be adjusted according to blood glucose readings, carbohydrate intake and physical activity.
  • Regular blood glucose monitoring and education to ensure people with type 1 diabetes can safely adjust their own insulin doses, particularly where access to trained health care professionals is limited.
  • In terms of insulin types administered,  the guidelines note that while both human insulin and insulin analogues may be used, human insulin may be preferred in settings where it is more affordable. 

WHO also recommends considering insulin pens over syringes, although the recommendation is conditional and based on very low-certainty evidence. The guidelines recognize that syringes remain an effective delivery option where pens are unavailable.

For monitoring, WHO recommends testing of glycated haemoglobin (HbA1c) levels, an indicator of glucose levels in the blood, at intervals of up to three months, with an HbA1c target of 7% or lower for most adults. It also recommends considering finger-prick blood glucose testing or continuous glucose monitoring, including both real-time and intermittently scanned devices. Where blood glucose testing is unavailable, urine glucose testing may be used as an alternative.

Humanitarian and emergency settings

Women and children line up for nutritional support at South Sudan’s Wedweil Refugee Settlement, Northern Bahr el Ghazal, 6 August 2026. The care for type 1 diabetes is incredibly vulnerable in humanitarian settings.

The guidelines give particular attention to the challenges of maintaining insulin treatment during humanitarian emergencies, when conflict, displacement and damage to health infrastructure can disrupt access to medicines and routine health services.

For people with T1D, an interruption in insulin treatment can quickly become life-threatening. Yet humanitarian responses have historically prioritized acute health needs, with chronic conditions such as diabetes often receiving less attention. Displacement can also leave people without their insulin, monitoring supplies or access to health care providers.

In Sudan, where a vicious civil war has raged since 2023, humanitarian partners have worked to deliver life-saving insulin. 

“Sudan’s healthcare system has suffered severe disruption, with over 60% of facilities rendered non-functional and essential medicine supply chains critically affected,” the International Diabetes Federation said. “For people living with diabetes, the collapse of the national power grid has posed an acute threat to insulin availability due to strict cold-chain requirements.” 

Against this backdrop, WHO still recommends that health care providers consider intensified insulin therapy for adults with T1D in emergency and humanitarian settings, where feasible. However, it acknowledges that maintaining this regimen may not always be possible when supplies are interrupted. Providers should therefore have contingency plans to transition people living with diabetes temporarily to simpler insulin regimens.

The guidelines also acknowledge that treatment options in humanitarian emergencies may be constrained by the availability and affordability of insulin and delivery devices. While human insulin is generally preferred because it is less expensive, WHO says choices must also account for the reliability and sustainability of local supplies. Ensuring access to blood glucose monitoring, training health workers and helping people living with diabetes manage their own treatment will be critical, particularly where specialist care is limited.

WHO cautions that the evidence underpinning the recommendations comes largely from outside humanitarian settings, leaving continued gaps in understanding how best to implement recommended practices during emergencies. 

The guidelines call on countries to incorporate the recommendations into national diabetes policies, essential medicines lists and health worker training programs.

“WHO will help countries turn these recommendations into actions by providing practical tools and guidance to track progress. Countries are also encouraged to actively involve people with type 1 diabetes in designing, implementing and evaluating diabetes programmes,”  WHO said in its press statement accompanying the guidelines’ release. 

Image Credits: WHO / Badru Katumba, isensusa/Unsplash, International Diabetes Federation, © WFP/Gabriela Vivacqua.

WHO's Dr Roseline Belzaire (centre) and Africa CDC's Dr Yap Boum on the ground in Ituri in the DRC to address Ebola.
WHO’s Dr Roseline Belzaire (centre) and Africa CDC’s Dr Yap Boum (right) in Ituri in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) to assist the country in addressing the Ebola Bundibugyo outbreak.

 Africa CDC’s Governing Board is expected to discuss the renewal of Director-General Jean Kaseya’s term on 22 November, according to a Health Policy Watch report. African governments should look beyond allegations and rebuttals. Whatever the outcome, they should ask for a documented basis for the decision and clear responsibility for keeping cross-border alerts, referrals and emergency support working.

Imagine that a district surveillance officer reports an unusual cluster of severe illness near a border. Some of those affected have recently crossed from a neighbouring country. The national public health institute needs to alert its counterpart, arrange laboratory confirmation and decide whether regional assistance is needed. The usual regional contact is unreachable. Who acknowledges the alert, who accepts the referral and who authorises support?

This is not a remote scenario. The ongoing Bundibugyo Ebola outbreak in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC),most recently updated by the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control on 16 November, makes reliable cross-border alerts, laboratory support and emergency assistance an immediate concern. 

A joint update on 15 November describes how Africa CDC and WHO coordinate support to affected and at-risk countries. The hypothetical alert illustrates the test that any leadership outcome at the Africa Centres for Disease Control and Prevention (Africa CDC) must pass. Member states should therefore ask for two commitments: a documented basis for the leadership decision, and clear responsibility for keeping cross-border public health cooperation working under any outcome.

What the AU should establish

On 16 November, Health Policy Watch reported allegations about staff treatment, regional redeployments and financial controls. Africa CDC rejected the report the following day, denied that Kaseya had been suspended or sanctioned, and cited the African Union (AU) Commission Chairperson’s favourable performance appraisal. As of 18 November, the renewal item remained publicly unconfirmed.

The financial dispute turns on what an audit can and cannot show. Africa CDC says its 2025 financial statements received an unmodified audit opinion, meaning auditors found them fairly presented in all material respects, and that outstanding bank-reconciliation items were cleared. 

Health Policy Watch reported control weaknesses described in an auditors’ management letter, the separate report in which auditors flag internal-control problems. Both can be true at once, so the AU needs the underlying records to assess corrective action. 

The personnel allegations call for a different process: confidential review with a fair opportunity to respond.

In July, the AU Executive Council reiterated its call for a time-bound investigation into the use of external partner funds under Africa CDC, and directed periodic reporting on implementation of audit recommendations to the AU Commission leadership. Member states should ask what follow-up the Commission has received and which actions remain open.

Article 19 (5) of the revised Africa CDC Statute provides for a four-year term, renewable once. For appointment, it describes a Board-led selection process and Assembly endorsement on the recommendation of the Committee of Heads of State and Government. The AU should clarify how the rules apply to the current renewal review and what evidence supports the decision.

Through the regional consultations provided for in Article 10, the Board can also gather evidence of what countries received. Health ministers on the Board could invite each country in their region to bring one documented request for Africa CDC support and answer four questions: What did the country ask for? Who took responsibility? What was delivered? What remains open? Read alongside the appraisal and verified records, these accounts would give the Board concrete examples of how Africa CDC responds to country requests and help identify which commitments must carry forward.

What countries have an interest in sustaining

Countries also have concrete gains to protect. Africa CDC’s 2025–2027 development plan for national public health institutes commits to designating regional centres of excellence and expanding peer support, and its 2025 annual report records nine centre designations. Ministers should ask: Which centres can countries call on today? What have they delivered? Which services depend on funding or staff appointments nearing expiry?

The joint Africa CDC–WHO mpox response shows what is worth carrying forward: a continental incident management team that coordinated technical assistance to countries, a joint review that informed later work plans, and tracking of pledges and disbursements. For a country awaiting help, continuity means knowing who will handle its open request and whether the resources to deliver it exist.

What each outcome would require

If the term is renewed, the Governing Board should ask Africa CDC to assign owners and deadlines for verified corrective actions, track progress through existing AU oversight, and tell member states which open country requests and commitments will be delivered, and by when.

If a recommendation is deferred under the applicable rules, the responsible AU bodies should state what evidence is outstanding, set a review date and confirm who can authorise regional assistance in the interim. Otherwise, a pause in the decision could become a pause in support, and an officer at a border could be left without a clear route to approval.

If leadership changes, Africa CDC should hand over open country requests, emergency commitments and related funding arrangements to designated officials. Each country with a request in progress should know who is taking it forward, and whom to call if that person is unavailable.

What national institutes can test now

The Ethiopia Public Health Institute, one of nine centres of excellence, could convene a regional simulation process to test regional readiness for an outbreak in the Horn of Africa.

National institutes need not wait for the AU’s decision to test the route that an alert would take. The International Health Regulations (IHR) already set out countries’ responsibilities for assessing events and notifying WHO through National IHR Focal Points, and Africa CDC’s Development Framework 2.0 gives institutes a basis for organising regional cooperation around them. What is often missing is a rehearsal.

Regional experience shows why rehearsal matters. Uganda ran an Ebola field simulation exercise as part of its 2018–2019 preparedness work. When cases crossed into Kasese in June 2019, a WHO case study highlighted cross-border information sharing and local surveillance. The lesson is to test the route from local detection to national action and cross-border cooperation while there is still time to fix it.

A regional peer exercise could make this concrete. Any of the nine designated centres of excellence could convene one. In the Horn of Africa, for example, a host such as the Ethiopian Public Health Institute (EPHI), this author’s own institution, could bring together Ethiopia’s Ministry of Health, neighbouring counterparts and Africa CDC’s Eastern Africa Regional Coordination Centre. 

Using WHO’s IHR simulation approach, participants would run the alert, the referral and the request for help through existing channels, assign each gap to a responsible institution and set a date to retest it.

The two commitments are simple. The Governing Board should record the evidence behind its recommendation. Africa CDC and national authorities should confirm the contacts, alternates and escalation routes that keep urgent cross-border cooperation working. Then, when the next alert comes, the surveillance officer at the border will know who will answer, where to send the referral and who can authorise help.

Feyiso Bati Wariso is a public health epidemiologist in the Infectious Diseases Research Directorate at the Ethiopian Public Health Institute (EPHI)in Addis Ababa. He was co-principal investigator on national SARS-CoV-2 seroprevalence surveys. His other research includes public health emergency workforce, Infectious disease and epidemics. The views expressed are his own.

 

Image Credits: X/Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, Africa CDC.

The World Health Organization headquarters in Geneva, where member states will elect the next Director-General from shortlisted candidates.
The World Health Organization headquarters in Geneva, where member states will elect the next Director-General from shortlisted candidates.

Four of the seven candidates vying to succeed Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus faced member-state questioning in Geneva on Wednesday. The hearings exposed sharp fault lines over budget cuts and regional manufacturing, though contenders refused to name programmes facing termination.

Wednesday’s hearing marked the first public forum in a race shaped by escalating health threats, geopolitical conflicts, funding shortfalls, and institutional reprioritisations. Delegations tested four distinct leadership philosophies competing ahead of May’s World Health Assembly vote.

The field featured former Qatari health minister Dr Hanan Mohamed Al Kuwari; Belgium’s nominee, WHO Europe director Dr Hans Henri P. Kluge; China’s maternal health veteran Dr Song Li and Botswana’s outsider nominee, Armenian paediatric oncologist Dr Gevorg Tamamyan.

The remaining three contenders face questions on Thursday: Dr Hanan Balkhy of Saudi Arabia, Spain’s Dr María Neira, and Indonesia’s Budi Gunadi Sadikin.

Inside the mechanics of the WHO candidate forum

Executive Board Chair Tandin Wangchuk draws lots with WHO Legal Counsel.
Executive Board Chair Tandin Wangchuk draws lots with WHO Legal Counsel.

While decisive commitments – vote-trading, bilateral alliances, and financial pledges – continue behind closed doors, the public forum provides a rare window into multilateral health diplomacy. First introduced during WHO governance reforms, the live-streamed hearings allow global scrutiny of candidate priorities and member-state pressure points.

Inside the hall, proceedings followed strict procedural mechanics established by the World Health Assembly. Opening statements were capped at 10 minutes, with two traffic-light systems enforcing speaking limits across the room.

Delegations submitted questioning requests by dropping colour-coded tokens into six regional ballot boxes circulating across the floor. The Executive Board chair drew lots to ensure each WHO geographic region posed an opening query. Secretariat staff then merged the remaining tokens into a single container for random selection.

Selected nations were restricted to a single 60-second question, and contenders had three minutes to reply within each 50-minute interrogation block.

Questions highlight geographic divides

 

A representative from Barbados addresses the forum, highlighting how funding rules exclude vulnerable island states.
A representative from Barbados addresses the forum, highlighting how financing and resource allocation rules disadvantage island states.

Across Wednesday’s four sessions, contenders answered a total of 63 questions, which highlighted a sharp geographic divide.

Donor governments concentrated at least 14 separate questions on normative standards, fiscal discipline, administrative consolidation, and terminating redundant programmes. Conversely, 19 questions from African, Latin American, and Asian delegations pressed on workforce retention, technology transfer, and sovereign biomanufacturing.

Low-income delegations, particularly from sub-Saharan Africa, treated the sessions as a test of operational survival. Their interventions targeted basic delivery failures, demanding that candidates explain how WHO would sustain primary care, reduce reliance on foreign-manufactured medicines, and shield conflict-affected populations from recurring funding cliffs.

Small Island Developing States (SIDS) pressed contenders to overhaul resource allocation formulas that disqualify middle-income islands from concessional technical assistance despite crushing climate threats and medical brain drain.

Meanwhile, Latin American middle-income economies warned that WHO routinely bypasses their non-communicable disease burdens and high, out-of-pocket health costs, demanding tailored partnerships rather than a one-size-fits-all model designed solely for the poorest states.

Qatar’s operational moderniser

Former Qatari health minister Dr Hanan Mohamed Al Kuwari pitches operational discipline and a refocus on core standards in Geneva.
Former Qatari health minister Dr Hanan Mohamed Al Kuwari pitches operational discipline and a refocus on core standards.

In her presentation, Al Kuwari leaned heavily on her track record leading Qatar’s health system, pitching herself as an operational reformer ready to instil strategic discipline in Geneva. Speaking with measured precision, she argued that WHO’s effectiveness is blunted when it spreads resources thin, urging the agency to refocus on core normative standards and tailor its country-level work directly to primary healthcare.

Her platform pitched rigorous functional reviews, digital transformation, and delegating operational field delivery to external partners while re-anchoring headquarters in standard-setting. Al Kuwari also drew a firm line between technical work and fundraising.

“I would like the department heads, project leads, directors not to worry about the financial situation and to leave that to a team of experts,” she said.

Kenya challenged her on regional manufacturing, noting that while prequalification opens factory doors, sustained orders keep them in business. Al Kuwari agreed, arguing that commercial viability requires public-private partnerships and concluding the Pandemic Agreement negotiations.

Al Kuwari also faces scrutiny from liberal member states over sensitive normative mandates. When Iceland pressed her on sexual and reproductive health and rights, she led with science and human rights.

“Our position will always be the science and protection of the rights of everybody regardless of race, nationality, gender, whatever, to health services,” said Al Kuwari. Asked by Health Policy Watch to clarify what the phrase “gender, whatever” encompasses, her campaign did not respond by publication deadline.

Belgian reformer and reckoning for big pharma

Playing to his linguistic strengths, Belgium’s nominee Dr Hans Henri P. Kluge presents his manifesto in all six UN languages.
Playing to his linguistic strengths, Belgium’s nominee Dr Hans Henri P. Kluge presents his manifesto in all six UN languages.

Kluge delivered an assertive, high-energy defence of pragmatic multilateralism, leaning heavily on his frontline crisis management across the European Region. Rejecting conventional UN austerity formulas, he emphasised that promising “more with less” or “same with less” carries “no credibility.”

Instead of cutting frontline muscle, he pointed to his region’s digital overhaul, reporting that developing in-house artificial intelligence tools had saved $1.3 million in staff time, avoided $340,000 in commercial software licensing fees, and recouped 15,500 working hours in a single year.

On global health equity, Kluge adopted an unexpectedly confrontational posture toward multinational pharmaceutical manufacturers. He pledged to summon pharmaceutical chief executives to Geneva “one by one” – mirroring the negotiations that produced the Pandemic Influenza Preparedness (PIP) Framework – insisting that corporate interests must not dictate who accesses life-saving therapies.

“It cannot be that pharmaceutical interests decide on who gets medicines or not,” said Kluge.

Addressing concerns over Africa’s dependence on imported medicines, he set a concrete operational deadline, projecting that pooled procurement and the African Medicines Agency could enable the continent to produce “15 to 20 vital medications” within six years.

When pressed by Ghana about how he would accelerate the Accra Reset, Kluge pledged that WHO would act as an agile technical secretariat, working “hand-in-hand” with regional bodies rather than competing for political primacy. He specifically singled out Africa CDC Director-General Jean Kaseya, referring to him warmly as “my other brother.”

This comes amid scrutiny over governance and leadership friction at Africa CDC. Asked by Health Policy Watch whether he was aware of staff complaints and formal enquiries regarding Kaseya’s tenure, Kluge did not respond.

The cross-regional institutional outsider

Botswana’s outsider nominee Dr Gevorg Tamamyan takes aim at Geneva’s institutional inertia, demanding radical accountability and frontline patient delivery.
Botswana’s outsider nominee Dr Gevorg Tamamyan takes aim at Geneva’s institutional inertia, demanding radical accountability and frontline patient delivery.

Botswana’s nominee Tamamyan upended diplomatic decorum, presenting himself as an unvarnished outsider taking aim at Geneva’s institutional inertia. Recounting how artificial intelligence calculated his odds of nomination outside Armenia at “zero” – drawing laughter from delegates – he contrasted multilateral diplomacy with bedside realities where patients die waiting for essential therapies.

“I have had to make health systems deliver where failure has consequences for actual patients,” said Tamamyan.

Challenging member states to hold him accountable, Tamamyan is the only contender pledging to step down after a single five-year term if an independent evaluation shows he achieved less than 80% of his targets. To halt unexecutable mandates, he proposed requiring every future World Health Assembly resolution to carry a binding delivery plan and designated funding source before adoption.

He also proposed publishing monthly leadership meeting minutes and an annual public report card. Alongside this, he urged shifting more WHO functions to countries based on need.

While the Armenian paediatric oncologist deflected several political blows with disarming candour, he was forced to concede his institutional inexperience when pressed on bureaucratic mechanics. When Spain asked how WHO should steer the complex future and transition of UNAIDS, Tamamyan refused to bluff diplomatic fluency.

“I don’t want to get into these details because I’m not an expert on this… Sorry for not being specific, but that’s my answer,” said Tamamyan. He acknowledged that while WHO must lead on health, he would rely on seasoned UN hands to manage inter-agency mechanics.

China’s disciplined pitch for Global South equity

China’s nominee Dr Song Li pitches multilateral stability and broader Global South representation on WHO’s expert advisory panels.
China’s nominee Dr Song Li pitches multilateral stability and broader Global South representation on WHO’s expert advisory panels.

Song adopted a disciplined, measured posture, presenting a vision anchored in multilateral stability, South-South cooperation, and institutional continuity. Drawing on decades of national experience in maternal and child health, she firmly resisted pressure to name programmes facing termination.

Song proposed broadening WHO’s expert advisory groups to include more scientists from Africa, small island states, and the Global South. She argued that global guidelines should reflect merit alongside wider geographic representation. On access to medical countermeasures, she championed voluntary licencing via the Medicines Patent Pool to foster local production before health emergencies strike.

When pressed on budget discipline, Song proposed deploying artificial intelligence to eliminate internal administrative bottlenecks. When asked what functions WHO should surrender, she argued existing inter-agency partnerships already prevent duplication.

Breaking briefly with her formal technical register when answering Chad on protecting displaced women and children, Song closed with an impassioned plea for peace: “All human beings… we are brothers, we are sisters, we are family. One family living in the one planet, the Earth.”

Australia posed the hearing’s most delicate question for a candidate backed by a global superpower. Delegates asked how she would demonstrate independence when WHO’s scientific advice differs from member states’ preferences. Song avoided direct friction, anchoring her approach in constitutional neutrality and serving all countries equally. She urged bringing more underrepresented nations onto technical advisory panels, subtly pushing back against the current balance of influence.

Nominating states cross-examine competing contenders

Indonesia’s delegation takes the floor after drawing tokens in three separate sessions to cross-examine rival WHO contenders.
Indonesia’s delegation takes the floor after drawing tokens in three separate sessions to cross-examine rival WHO contenders.

Delegations fielding their own contenders used the lottery to cross-examine rivals. Five of the seven nominating governments were drawn from the ballot boxes, turning diplomatic floor time into strategic vetting.

Indonesia proved the most persistent challenger, successfully drawing tokens in three separate sessions. Jakarta interrogated Al Kuwari on delivering primary healthcare at scale, pressed Kluge on shielding national priorities from earmarked donor funding, and challenged Tamamyan to identify which unfunded mandates he would abandon.

European contender sponsor Belgium used its floor time to interrogate China’s Song Li, pressing her on where she would look first to dismantle administrative complexity and simplify WHO workflows.

Outsider Tamamyan faced a concentrated barrage from rival sponsors. Spain questioned him on WHO’s role in the UNAIDS transition, while China asked who defines institutional priorities. Saudi Arabia pressed him on how an outsider could resolve WHO’s sustainable financing crisis.

Conflicting mandates await the victor

Member states convene in Geneva, underscoring the conflicting demands for austerity and expanded support awaiting WHO’s next Director-General.
Member states convene in Geneva, underscoring the conflicting demands for austerity and expanded support awaiting WHO’s next Director-General.

Wednesday’s forum confirmed that member states demand conflicting outcomes from their next chief executive – no matter what pledges the candidates make on the campaign trail. Major contributors want budget discipline, while Global South delegations push for equitable, expanded technical intervention and regional and national sovereignty.

The candidates demonstrated formidable stamina and command of multilateral jargon. Yet each candidate retreated to process and committees when pressed to name concrete budgetary eliminations.

Hearings resume Thursday, when delegations will interrogate the remaining three contenders in Geneva. In January, the 34-member Executive Board will interview a shortlist of five candidates and nominate up to three finalists before a final vote in May.

Note: Explore all candidate profiles and election coverage on our WHO election microsite. Profiles and coverage will be updated as the race progresses.

See related story:

Are WHO Member States Ready for Fundamental Change? From Institutional Survival to Global Health Leadership

Image Credits: Wikipedia , WHO.

Vote on UN resolution on eliminating violence against women and girls, 17 November 2026.

Somalia was the lone country voting against a United Nations (UN) resolution on “intensifying efforts to prevent and eliminate violence against women and girls” on Tuesday, while the United States and Russia were among the six countries that abstained.

The resolution urges member states to “take comprehensive and gender-responsive measures” to prevent and eliminate all forms of “violence, intimidation and attacks” against all women and girls, and to address risk factors by implementing legislation and policies. 

Its definition of violence extends to online and digital technologies, and urges countries to adopt laws and policies to protect women and girls from defamation and hate speech in online spaces.

Digital violence

Introducing the draft, France stressed the importance of the resolution’s focus on the digital landscape, noting that over half of women in some parts of the world have been affected by online violence.

In August, a report from the UN Secretary-General on progress made to eliminate gender-based violence noted that almost 50,000 women and girls were killed by their partners or another family member in 2024.

“Technology has extended the continuum of violence against women and girls into the digital sphere, where online harms increasingly function as precursors to and instruments of lethal violence,” noted the report. 

“Online stalking, digital surveillance and harassment extend coercive control beyond the physical environment,” it added, singling out “GPS tracking, spyware and monitoring applications” which enabled perpetrators to locate victims.

The resolution, sponsored by France and the UK, had been the subject of lengthy debate – as has been the case for most UN resolutions concerning women, girls and gender in the past few years.

Various member states contested terminology such as “sexual and reproductive health” and “safe abortion”.

Argentina, Burkina Faso, Belarus and Cameroon also abstained.

Sovereignty opt-out defeated

A proposed amendment, which was defeated by , wanted the entire resolution to be subjected to “national sovereignty”.

Nine civil society groups warned that this would undermine multilateralism by adding “a general sovereignty caveat” that would undermine “the process, the international human rights framework and the agreements on which this text rests”. 

“If accepted here, the same approach could be applied to any resolution in the future,” noted the groups, which include Amnesty International, the Center for Reproductive Rights, Human Rights Watch, International Planned Parenthood Federation and the International Service for Human Rights.

“This is not how sovereignty has been understood in the human rights system,” they pointed out. 

“The Vienna Declaration and Programme of Action addressed this question directly: while the significance of national and regional particularities and of various historical, cultural and religious backgrounds must be borne in mind, it is the duty of States, regardless of their political, economic and cultural systems, to promote and protect all human rights.”

Other member states sought to remove “non-consensual language”, including references to “multiple and intersecting forms of discrimination,” “intimate partner violence” and “marital rape”.

However, several delegations said that the amendments represented “backsliding,” harming the substance of the resolution.

‘Global scourge’

“Every 10 minutes, a woman is killed by her partner or a family member. This is appalling. And it must end,” said the UK, which co-sponsored the resolution.

Welcoming the resolution, the European Union at the UN noted: “Gender-related killings are a global scourge. Today’s vote: 175 to 1 marks the international community’s commitment to end violence against women and girls worldwide.”

The US explained in a statement that was disappointed to see the “controversial terminology” of ‘sexual and reproductive health’ and ‘safe abortion’ in the resolution.  

“There is no international ‘right to abortion,’ whether under that name or under other terms like ‘sexual and reproductive health’,” it added.

As the resolution has only been approved at the committee level during the 81st session, it still needs to be formally adopted in December by the General Assembly.